Browse › Engines ›Engine comparisons

Easiest swap??

Started by drift_addict · May 2, 2005 · 8postsSMF 2010–26

drift_addictMay 2, 2005, 3:56 am · #1

Well after searching extensively throughout the net and on here as well I have learned quite a bit about S12\'s. I will be driving mine doing mostly body work on it, replacing the quarters and repainting it flat black. Getting suspension in order as well as a decent set of 15s. I am just wondering as far as work, getting parts afterwards and initial cost...what would be the easiest swap and why, as I am looking to start the swap project come this fall. Thanks.

Jokes801tmcMay 2, 2005, 5:13 am · #2

CA18et or SR20det are the probably the easiest swaps

Joel07May 2, 2005, 6:25 am · #3

Well, there\'s really a bunch of swaps that are pretty close in terms of easiest.  I would say that the easiest is gonna be the CA18DET.  It uses the stock motor mounts, can bolt up to your stock tranny if need be, and I think it\'ll even use the stock driveshaft and tranny mount (not 100% sure on that though).

Then there\'s the SR20 and the KA, which I would say are about even because you still have the same amount of wiring, and they both use the same motor mounts.

And, if you\'re talking about any swap into a CA20 car, then the CA18ET would probably be hands down the easiest.  Direct bolt in replacement, just get the wiring harness and ecu, you\'ll have to do a little bit of rewiring, but nothing major.

And there\'s also the VG30E, which might be a pain unless you find an S12 SE in the junkyard, as they have a crossmember and oil pan that is specific to the S12 VG.

So all in all, I would say the CA18ET is the easiest, followed closely by the CA18DET.

bartc_jMay 2, 2005, 6:48 am · #4

ca18et is easiest then
ca18det
vg303
fj20et
sr20det

drift_addictMay 2, 2005, 7:04 am · #5

Well it is slowly looking like the 18ET is the way to go then huh. I have seen and read about some decent numbers from this little motor as well. At least I was impressed anyways, thanks for all your input.

bartc_jMay 2, 2005, 7:09 am · #6

ya the ca18et is way under appreciated.. every body thinks that the dohc is the way to go t attain some nice hp #\'s.... but thats not true at all and i think i have been doing a good job at proving that right... within a few months i should have a 300-375 sohc monster prowling the roads...

drift_addictMay 2, 2005, 7:12 am · #7

Amazing, a good friend of mine has a 6th gen Civic identical to mine, using the SOHC D16Y7 and he eats B16\'s all day long. He is running a modified Edelbrock kit. SOHC in general I think are underestimated when it comes to performance. Those are some impressive numbers for sure Bart what are you running turbo and management wise??

Joel07May 2, 2005, 2:07 pm · #8

SOHC\'s are definetly underrated in turbo form.  People don\'t understand that huge ports and valves aren\'t needed when you\'re turbo\'d.  When you get into the ultra-high race stuff it does, but for street applications, there\'s not much difference.  There\'s a lot of SOHC KA guys making close to 400 whp on mild setups, and there\'s pioneers like Bart running 13.3\'s on a bone stock long block with the little CA...  Bart\'s my hero...   :bow: