Browse › Engines ›Engine comparisons

Best Motor

Started by poss12 · Sep 4, 2004 · 9postsSMF 2010–26

poss12Sep 4, 2004, 8:58 am · #1

Hey All,

Instead of beating each other to death over which motor is best overall why not discuss which is the best for a particular application.

For myself I am after something that is reliable for 600k\'s a week as resonably fuel efficient as well as easy and cheap to fix (as well as having some guts).These are my needs but some else might want something different. If I was 18 again (sigh) I would be after something to blast all comers off the road.

Lets see some positive comments here.

Joel07Sep 4, 2004, 12:30 pm · #2

Oh lord, I know it wasn\'t your intention, but I can see this thread getting nasty pretty quick too...  :laugh:

I\'m not sure what kind of parts are readily available in Aus, so I\'m not really one to give my opinion on this thread...

JohnnyfiveSep 4, 2004, 3:00 pm · #3

ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRGHH!!! This is what this and every other thread on the subject does grrr!

bartc_jSep 4, 2004, 7:47 pm · #4

what power levels are you looking for and what kind of driving on the ide so you like

salps12Sep 5, 2004, 4:02 am · #5

Basically if its for the S12 then its the CA20E. They run for a long while and are pretty fuel efficient. In Aus the CA20s are everywhere so they will be cheap to replace if something bad happens.
If you want a bit more power but still cheap with fuel i suppose you could get a CA18DE from a S13. Bolt straight in using same tranny and exhaust from cat back.

:throwup:

SHEPPO3930Sep 5, 2004, 4:14 am · #6

CA18DE is best, better fuel economy than a CA20e, more power and will be zippy in the S12. they are reliable motors (ma mate has never had a problem) also, they have a fair bit of aftermarket support.

GL

one_equals_twoSep 5, 2004, 4:03 pm · #7

I\'d go with an LS1 from a Holden.  It will take a little more work to fit than a CA series engine, but it will get 30mpg, make 350HP in stock form.  It will probably be more expensive than a CA series engine in Australia, but in the US it would be a lot cheaper for parts.  Also, they are very reliable.

salps12Sep 5, 2004, 9:00 pm · #8

heh... saying that there is little work to fit an ls1 is like saying the vg30dett is a drop in  :no: eheheh

Dan0myteSep 5, 2004, 9:22 pm · #9

The best motor is the new V10 coming out from BMW for the M5. Now fitting that into an S12, that\'s a waste of time. ;)

You should really word your questions better. The way it sits right now, it\'s way too open.